Design law journal

Kategorie: Office and court proceedings

A web archive timestamp: what does it prove in an invalidity case?

An archived product description bears a date, but its image loads from another address. Check whether the archived snapshot includes the specific image relied on.

Appealing a design judgment: reviewing first-instance comparisons

A judgment describes a feature barely visible in the reproduced photograph. Start with the images that were before the court.

An EUIPO appeal: addressing the reasoning of the decision

Focus the grounds of appeal on where the Office assessed the comparison differently. Identify the passage, match it to the relevant images and explain why the finding affects the outcome.

An appeal to the Federal Patent Court: from decision to grounds

The Design Division assessed an earlier design differently from the company. Assemble the decision’s reasoning, the images actually filed and proof of service.

A refusal after Hague registration: identifying the decision to answer

A WIPO notification concerns only one designated contracting party and certain designs. Extract the reference, affected designs, grounds and competent office into a table.

EUIPO invalidity cases: keeping image, source and date together

An older blog names a model and a second document supplies a photograph. Check whether both really concern the same design.

DPMA invalidity proceedings: preparing an earlier catalogue as evidence

A supplier provides only the product page of an earlier catalogue. For the application, establish which design the supplier made available, when and to whom.