Design law journal
Function or design choice? Recording development decisions
Design law journal · Archive date 2026-05-18
Searches and validity · Product development, Technical function
A team tested three grip contours for a control. Specifications, ergonomic trials and approval records can show which requirements influenced its choice.
Keep rejected alternatives and the reasons for rejection. The mere existence of an alternative does not settle the legal assessment.
Legal background
Features dictated solely by technical function may be excluded from design protection. Mechanical connections, modular systems and public policy exclusions each require separate consideration.
Four practical examples
- Wheel rim: Examine the spoke pattern and earlier designs in the same product group.
- Bag: Compare the silhouette and distinctive clasp.
- Lamp: Identify features dictated by technical constraints.
- Presentation: Reconstruct the date and audience of the first showing.
Further reading: Exclusions from design protection.