Design law journal
Was the lamp already public? Reconstructing disclosure
Design law journal · Archive date 2025-03-18
Searches and validity · Disclosure, Novelty
The development file contains a studio photograph, a dealer newsletter and a later product page. All show the lamp, but only two were circulated externally or published.
For each version, identify the image, audience and date. Then check which features could actually be seen in each disclosure.
Legal background
An earlier disclosure defeats novelty if the designs are identical or differ only in immaterial details. The filing or priority date, accessibility to specialist circles and any applicable grace period matter.
Four practical examples
- Wheel rim: Examine the spoke pattern and earlier designs in the same product group.
- Bag: Compare the silhouette and distinctive clasp.
- Lamp: Identify features dictated by technical constraints.
- Presentation: Reconstruct the date and audience of the first showing.
Further reading: When is a design new?.
Official source: DPMA · Requirements for protection (German).