Design law journal
Individual character of a bag: looking beyond the clasp
Design law journal · Archive date 2025-09-18
Searches and validity · Individual character, Product comparison
Two bags have similar clasps but different proportions and side profiles. Compare each earlier model separately with the filed design.
Mark individual features to guide the reader, then return to the overall impression and take account of the designer’s freedom for this type of product.
Legal background
Novelty concerns whether an identical design was previously disclosed. Individual character turns on the overall impression on the informed user, taking account of the designer’s freedom. We prepare a dated visual comparison for each earlier design cited.
Four practical examples
- Wheel rim: Examine the spoke pattern and earlier designs in the same product group.
- Bag: Compare the silhouette and distinctive clasp.
- Lamp: Identify features dictated by technical constraints.
- Presentation: Reconstruct the date and audience of the first showing.
Further reading: Assess novelty and individual character.
Official source: DPMA · Requirements for protection (German).