Design law journal
Design law journal
Articles are grouped by editorial archive date. Entries for earlier periods were prepared retrospectively.
2026
2026-11-18 · Searches and validity
The overall impression of a wheel rim: presenting earlier designs clearly
Spoke count and direction are easy to describe. Comparing like angles and sizes makes the visual assessment more useful.
2026-11-06 · Office and court proceedings
A web archive timestamp: what does it prove in an invalidity case?
An archived product description bears a date, but its image loads from another address. Check whether the archived snapshot includes the specific image relied on.
2026-10-18 · Portfolio management
Reading a register extract: ownership, status and their limits
A buyer receives an older register extract attached to the sale agreement. Compare its retrieval date, owner and views with the current record.
2026-10-06 · Office and court proceedings
Appealing a design judgment: reviewing first-instance comparisons
A judgment describes a feature barely visible in the reproduced photograph. Start with the images that were before the court.
2026-09-18 · Office and court proceedings
An EUIPO appeal: addressing the reasoning of the decision
Focus the grounds of appeal on where the Office assessed the comparison differently. Identify the passage, match it to the relevant images and explain why the finding affects the outcome.
2026-09-06 · Office and court proceedings
An appeal to the Federal Patent Court: from decision to grounds
The Design Division assessed an earlier design differently from the company. Assemble the decision’s reasoning, the images actually filed and proof of service.
2026-08-18 · Office and court proceedings
A refusal after Hague registration: identifying the decision to answer
A WIPO notification concerns only one designated contracting party and certain designs. Extract the reference, affected designs, grounds and competent office into a table.
2026-08-06 · Design contracts and licensing
Settling a dispute over stock: what can still be sold?
The parties agree to a limited sell-off but still have goods in fulfilment centres, returns and outstanding replenishment orders. A schedule can record quantities, locations and the cut-off date, and specify how sales are evidenced.
2026-07-12 · Design filing and protection
Animated interfaces: which sequence belongs in a design filing?
An app moves an icon across the screen as it switches from search to checkout. Preserve the start, transition and end as a coherent sequence.
2026-06-18 · Design filing and protection
Coordinating a national filing abroad: briefing local counsel
Sales wants to enter just one additional market. To compare a national filing with an international designation, give local counsel the same images, applicant details and launch date.
2026-06-06 · Office and court proceedings
EUIPO invalidity cases: keeping image, source and date together
An older blog names a model and a second document supplies a photograph. Check whether both really concern the same design.
2026-05-18 · Searches and validity
Function or design choice? Recording development decisions
A team tested three grip contours for a control. Specifications, ergonomic trials and approval records can show which requirements influenced its choice.
2026-05-06 · Infringement and enforcement
Infringement claims after a model change: which version is challenged?
A retailer replaces listing images during correspondence, while the delivered sample still matches the older version. Initially treat them separately and match each to orders, screenshots and dates.
2026-04-18 · Searches and validity
A logo on a product: planning design protection and trade mark use
A start-up uses its symbol as a repeated pattern and as an indication of origin on a label. Set the two uses side by side.
2026-04-06 · Infringement and enforcement
A protective brief before launch: pinning down the expected claim
Following a lawyer’s letter, an importer expects an application for urgent relief. Identify the model version, rights holder and company actually targeted.
2026-03-18 · Office and court proceedings
DPMA invalidity proceedings: preparing an earlier catalogue as evidence
A supplier provides only the product page of an earlier catalogue. For the application, establish which design the supplier made available, when and to whom.
2026-03-06 · Infringement and enforcement
Urgent relief before a trade fair: building a usable chronology
A fair is imminent, but the first photograph of the competing product appeared in an older chat. The exhibition calendar alone is insufficient for an urgent application.
2026-02-18 · Searches and validity
From a social media post to filing: identifying first disclosure
The social team knows the official launch date, but the designer recalls an earlier public teaser. Preserve both posts with dates, images and account ownership.
2026-02-06 · Design contracts and licensing
Drawing boundaries between product lines: why a sketch helps
Two suppliers negotiate over similarly shaped containers. “A different colour” leaves the next lid or recessed grip unresolved. An agreement can attach approved views and specify how future departures will be reviewed.
2026-01-12 · Searches and validity
Components in use: what can the end user actually see?
A manufacturer wants protection for an appliance cover. Every surface is visible on the workbench, but only the face and rim show once fitted.
2025
2025-12-18 · Portfolio management
Budgeting for renewals: which models are still worth maintaining?
Designs in a multiple application rarely perform equally well. Before budgeting, match each model to a product family and market.
2025-12-06 · Portfolio management
Annual design inventory: matching registrations to the product range
The register list contains a number while the sales system shows only a product name. Link them using item numbers, images and the responsible business unit.
2025-11-18 · Infringement and enforcement
Suspected counterfeits at the border: preparing an identification sheet
Customs officers need to recognise suspect consignments in a packaging range. Use clear photographs, variant names and contacts who can respond quickly.
2025-11-06 · Design contracts and licensing
Joint development with a university: who may publish and when?
A research team plans a conference poster while its industry partner wants to decide about filing first. The collaboration agreement can set a process for submitting specific images, receiving comments and granting clearance.
2025-10-18 · Infringement and enforcement
A warning letter reaches procurement: what to request from the supplier
A warning letter concerns goods sold under a retailer’s private label. Collect the supply contract, product records and photographs of the version actually delivered.
2025-10-06 · Design filing and protection
One image set for several territories? Preparing a Hague filing
A lighting range is intended for Germany, the United States and Japan. Compare the desired designations with the views already available before filing internationally.
2025-09-18 · Searches and validity
Individual character of a bag: looking beyond the clasp
Two bags have similar clasps but different proportions and side profiles. Compare each earlier model separately with the filed design.
2025-09-06 · Infringement and enforcement
Marketplace complaints: a listing number alone is not evidence
A seller groups four colour variants under one heading. Only two listings show the disputed shape.
2025-08-18 · Portfolio management
New company name or new owner? Choosing the right register request
A group brings several product companies under one brand. New letterhead alone does not establish what the register should say.
2025-08-06 · Infringement and enforcement
A suspected copy at a trade fair: what the first photographs should show
A sales representative spots a similar product on the last day of a fair. A close-up may show its shape without identifying the seller.
2025-07-12 · Design contracts and licensing
Buying a design when changing agencies: what happens to source files?
A new agency takes over a product line. The server contains renders but no editable CAD files.
2025-06-18 · Design filing and protection
Between filing and launch: planning publication
A brand wants to file early but unveil its collection at a trade fair. Track filing, intended publication, production and public sampling as separate dates.
2025-06-06 · Design filing and protection
A runway debut: preserving evidence for a fashion collection
A collection debuts on the runway and later appears in a lookbook with revised details. For an unregistered EU design, it can matter exactly what was visible at the first showing.
2025-05-18 · Searches and validity
Before ordering tooling: assess design risk in the target market
A mould for a handle is expensive, while changing a CAD contour can still be relatively inexpensive. Review the design at the final approval stage before ordering tooling.
2025-05-06 · Design filing and protection
From Community design to EU design: reading older register files
Since 1 May 2025, businesses have encountered new terminology in EUIPO materials. Older licence schedules may still refer to a Community design.
2025-04-18 · Design filing and protection
From first filing to export: preparing the priority file
A foreign distributor comes on board only after the German launch. For a subsequent filing, assemble the first filing receipt, original views and current ownership details.
2025-04-06 · Design contracts and licensing
Hotel interiors and retail sales: defining a furniture licence
A licensee will supply armchairs to hotels. A retailer later offers the same model online.
2025-03-18 · Searches and validity
Was the lamp already public? Reconstructing disclosure
The development file contains a studio photograph, a dealer newsletter and a later product page. All show the lamp, but only two were circulated externally or published.
2025-03-06 · Design contracts and licensing
Commissioning packaging: artwork, print files and rights
An agency supplies a PDF for approval. The printer later needs editable files, and the client wants a second pack size.
2025-02-18 · Searches and validity
An armchair in an old catalogue: how to document a search result
A cropped photograph shows a strikingly similar armrest but gives no publication year. Keep the cover, publication details, relevant page and evidence of circulation together.
2025-02-06 · Design contracts and licensing
Showing a prototype at a pitch: who can share the images?
A manufacturer invites three agencies to pitch and sends them the same download link. Before sharing the files, settle whether outside photographers or model makers may see them.
2025-01-12 · Design filing and protection
Filing a chair collection: which backrest belongs in which set of views?
Three chairs share a seat and frame but have different backrests. The catalogue shows them together.